RuPaul's new show, RuPaul's Drag U, premiered last night. Georg and I were both big fans of her hit show, RuPaul's Drag Race, of which this is sort of a spinoff.
RuPaul's Drag Race is basically America's Next Top Model with professional drag queens instead of teenage would-be models, and RuPaul instead of Tyra. If that description doesn't appeal to you, you probably skipped this entire entry and aren't reading now. Trust me, it's fantastic.
The concept of RuPaul's Drag U is less interesting to me: in each episode three former Drag Race contestants give a drag-style makeover to three biological women. The women have to wear big costumes, big wigs and big makeup, walk the runway, and do a lip sync performance. They are judged and the winner gets $10,000.
I don't generally watch makeover shows. I'm kind of put off by the tearful confessionals & the conceit that a TV show can improve someone's life by giving them a new outfit and some makeup tips. That said, if I had the opportunity to get a new outfit and makeup tips from a drag queen, hell yeah I'd do it. I'm, shall we say, a fan of elaborate costumes, and no one does costumes better than a drag queen. And most of the Drag Race contestants I really liked are on this show (everyone I had hoped for except Jessica Wild). So of course I watched Drag U.
It's almost by definition not as good as Drag Race, simply because more time spent on the makeovers means less time spent on the drag queens. It seemed like the drag queens weren't exactly sure whether the show was about them or the makover-ees. For instance Jujubee seemed to focus on the woman she was helping, while Raven clearly wanted all of her face time to be all about herself.
What I liked: Most of all, RuPaul's sense of humor. The funniest thing in the entire episode was when RuPaul advised one of the women to "Take a page from my book. No, really. [takes autobiography off a shelf] It's right here. Take it." I only wish she'd made the woman actually tear out a page. RuPaul also used that creaky old "walk this way" gag to great effect. And Jujubee had a funny exchange with her makeover-ee, who put on a tight dress after wearing nothing but pants for years:
"Do you feel powerful?"
"I feel like a sausage."
"Do you feel like a powerful sausage?"
What I didn't like: the idea, implied throughout the episode and stated outright once or twice, that the makeover subjects, all "tomboys" who never wore makeup, were not fully women until the drag queens taught them how. I'm all for playing around with the expectations of gender roles. A man who wears dresses, acts out an exaggerated version of femininity, and calls himself a queen is no less of a man. Likewise a woman who rides a Harley, hates dresses and makeup, and calls herself a biker chick or a tomboy is no less of a woman.
When Raven said "They were boys when they walked in here, and now they're women," she couldn't have been more wrong. Whether they were in jeans or gowns, they were always women. No one can give womanhood to them because no one can take it away.
I was also deeply uncomfortable when one of the makeover-ees said that she never wore dresses because she had a history of sexual assault and she felt unsafe in feminine clothing. That was where I felt the show crossed the line into exploitation. (A line that Drag Race never crossed in my opinion, because the contestants were all professional drag performers using the show to promote their careers.) That woman needs counseling, not a reality tv show.
I'll continue watching Drag U, just to see more of favorites like Nina Flowers and Pandora Boxx. But I'll be glad when this show is over and the next season of Drag Race starts up.
Recent Comments