blegh

| 2 Comments

I've got one of those headaches. The kind where I'm sitting in the dark using my computer, because I couldn't handle the noise of the TV, and I had to turn the brightness of the laptop almost all the way down because even that was too much.

Good thing I don't have a Battlestar Galatica DVD tonight; that would be a dilemma. I have 2 movies at a time from Netflix, and I've been watching them as fast as they come in, and so I get 2 DVDs every 3 days unless I mess up and forget to put one in the mail.

I've seen the first few episodes of season 2 and I'm enjoying it immensely. I like that season 2 seems to be focusing entirely on the over-arching story, keeping the pace moving all the time, with very few "one-off" type episodes.

My only criticism of the plot is this thing about the prophecy and the arrow and so forth. It annoys me that the President would have a drug-induced fantasy, would decide that this fantasy is a prophecy coming true, and would bring down the entire government in her attempt to fulfill the prophecy, and this is portrayed as noble and principled. Regardless of how fantastical a science fiction story, its characters have to behave in a believable, realistic way within the story. And in reality, when a person has drug-induced fantasies that sound kind of like a religious prophecy, that person is not the fulfillment of the prophecy. That person needs to lay off the drugs.

Things which seem like meaningful coincidences happen all the time, and people assign significance to them, but they actually mean nothing. In real life if you think some odd coincidence means you're the focus of an ancient prophecy, you're wrong. If you risk your safety, your government, and your entire species trying to act out that prophecy, you're not heroic. Except that this isn't reality, it's a TV show. And in a TV show, prophecies are always real, and the person trying to fulfill them is always doing the right thing. Because why would you even mention a prophecy in a work of fiction if you weren't going to have it come true later on? It's Chekhov's gun at its most gross and unsubtle. The President is behaving like she knows she's in a TV show.

For me the only satisfying outcome of this prophecy storyline is if the President is completely, absolutely wrong. Like if it turns out that there's nothing in the tomb, they can't find Earth that way, and besides which she isn't even dying. (It would be interesting if that cranky doctor found a way to cure her cancer, but she didn't want to let him because she was so wrapped up in this crazy prophecy which requires a dying leader.) Or maybe if the prophecy would have been true, but by trying to force it to happen prematurely she has undone it. I could live with that too. Please, please don't tell me what actually happens. Let me enjoy my ignorance while I can.

2 Comments

Sounds like you're a few episodes ahead of me (I watched the first two episodes of season 2 yesterday), so perhaps you can help me:

(preferably by not answering my question and yelling 'spoiler' if the answer would involve spoilers)

I'm really confused by the Kobol/Caprica planet.
So they found a habitable planet, far away in unknown space, decided it was Kobol, went there to pick up the arrow in some ancient ruins - and at the same time it was Caprica, where most of the crew had been living, and Starbuck still has a cozy, paint-splattered apartment?
Huh?

Could be I missed the explanation, I've been knitting furiously while watching it.
Or it could be it will be explained later, in which case, please don't say anything.

Hi, Bummble! I don't think this is a spoiler. The way I interpreted it is: they are 2 different planets. The Galactica discovered a planet which they think is Kobol (the captions confirm it, so it probably is), and then Starbuck jumped all the way back to Caprica to get the arrow, which is in a museum. That's why Starbuck had to steal the Cylon ship, because the humans didn't have a ship with the capability to jump that far. And that's why she ran into Helo, who never left Caprica. Make sense?

ps: what are you knitting?

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Sarah published on October 18, 2007 8:17 PM.

r.i.p. joey bishop was the previous entry in this blog.

update is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Monthly Archives

Pages